“The said Johne is be the hand of God dum and defe and unnaturale.” The OED offers this quotation as an example of the use of the word in the 1500s, bringing in religion and God into its meaning. This use of the word existed little less than a century ago and today we see the existence of the word under different circumstances. Society today speaks of Unnatural Acts, and uses this to form a government and laws based on the most common act (and so deemed the most natural). Homosexuality, for example, is called unnatural by society and certain subcultures within it. The Vatican has defined the Christian doctrine as follows, “‘every genital act must be within the framework of marriage.’ Premarital sex, masturbation, and homosexuality are specifically condemned.” Further, the Christian doctrine speaks of homosexual sex as unnatural because it is sex that does not lead to procreation, in other words homosexual sex creates no offspring. As I stated above unnatural is defined as something that does not exist in nature. However, when used to define unnatural homosexual acts, it does not carry this meaning. For instance, there are many things that have been developed by society that would not, by definition, be considered natural. Yet, they are not condemned simply because they are a common practice, such as taking drugs to cure illnesses. The negative connotation that the word unnatural carries today in the western word comes from the use of this word to mean not common, abnormal, or strange.
In John Corvino’s Why Shouldn’t Tommy and Jim Have Sex? A Defense of Homosexuality, Corvino explains, “It often seems that when people call homosexuality ‘unnatural’ they really just mean that it’s disgusting” (White, 271). Similarly, we have seen other lifestyles deemed disgusting and unnatural by the popular opinion of a subculture. One example is the spread of Western Ideology with the use of globalization and missionary work taken to countries that are not as advanced in technology. The Sambia of New Guinea are an example of a way of life turned unnatural, disgusting and abnormal. The Sambia culture held the belief on initiating a boy into adulthood by the consumption of semen from an older man. As this became known in the western world it became something shameful, and slowly this way of life has come to an end.
Technology and globalization as well as culture shifts have given a new meaning to the word unnatural, changed it from its root to a negative term not meaning something not occurring from birth, or biology to a word stating deformity or burden by god, and finally to today’s meaning of something out the social norm.
“unnatural.” OxfordEnglishDictionary.com. 2nd edition. 11 Sept. 2008.
"nature." Dictionary.com Unabridged (v 1.1). Random House, Inc. 11 Sep. 2008.
White, James E. Contemporary Moral Problems. Learning, Inc. Thompson learning.
2006. Belmont, Ca.
1 comment:
I can see you put thought into this entry and your examples and outside texts are well chosen. To make this even stronger, you could have related it to its root, “natural.” Also the post has a rough start, “The Western word defines society in terms of norms and common practices; for instance most of the time the majority actually does rule.” I am not sure what you mean by this statement and, I think you meant to write “world” instead of “word”? Overall, I really see in an improvement in your writing and the care with which you have approached the assignments. I realize this course was not easy for you, but thank you for your hard work and perseverance.
Post a Comment